BREAKING & UPDATED: First Case OF CWD Confirmed In Ohio On Hunting Preserve

This is the just-released joint notice by the Ohio Department of Natural Resources and the Ohio Department of Agriculture that CWD has appeared in a sampled Ohio deer. The animal - a buck - originally came from Pennsylvania and was transferred to an unnamed Ohio big-game hunting preserve, located in Holmes County. This story will be updated pending further information requested of both Natural Resources and Agricultural Department spokeswomen. - Jeffrey L. Frischkorn 

UPDATED with the following additions as of 9 p.m., October: 23:

With the confirmation of a CWD-contaminated deer, Ohio now becomes the 14th state in which the always-fatal disease has been discovered in a captive deer herd.

The CWD-infected buck deer came from the "World Class Whitetails of Ohio" big-game hunting preserve near Millersburg in Holmes County, news accounts citing an Ohio Department of Agriculture official.

The preserve's web site (www.bestdeerohio.com) says it offers three day/two night hunts with several  bucks in the 260-inch class being available and prides itself on a 99.8-percent success rate.

While a detailed list of hunt costs was not found, the ranch's web site does post a special for $6,900.

An email has been sent to World Class Whitetails of Ohio seeking comment and additional information about the CWD-infected buck deer.


And a spokeswoman for the Ohio Division of Wildlife says the agency's efforts now will continue with its monitoring program. That application will include collecting deer heads from road kills, hunter-generated harvests, processed deer, taxidermy shops as ell as increasing "Our outreach to the local community," says Susie Vance, a Wildlife Division spokeswoman. 

Not one the agenda - at least not yet - is a prohibitive order from the Wildlife Division to cease the baiting of deer by hunters within a prescribed zone around any site found to be contaminated with CWD. In most states with a confirmed positive CWD finding and where baiting is legal, such a restriction is common.

Ohio's wildlife managers have discussed an interest in adopting such protocols should CWD ever be found in the state.

But Vance says that option is not yet in the picture.

"Regarding the wild population, the regulation of feeding deer is not our focus at this time," Vance said.

As for acting prudently and swiftly, Vance said the Agriculture Department did outstanding detective work in backtracking the sale of deer into Ohio from Pennsylvania deer-breeding businesses. Pennsylvania is a state known to harbor CWD-infected deer.

"Had we known the deer was infected up front we certainly would not have allowed the animal into Ohio," Vance said as well. "And since the finding we don't allow the importation of any deer from any other state."

A request for the names and locations of the still-under-quarantine big-game hunting preserves and deer farms is being worked by the Ohio Department of Agriculture, an agency spokeswoman said.

This story will either be updated as further information becomes available or else will become a separate blog posting. 

"REYNOLDSBURG, OHIO – The Ohio Department of Agriculture (ODA) and the Ohio Department of Natural Resources (ODNR) today confirmed the first positive case of Chronic Wasting Disease (CWD) in the state in a captive deer herd in Holmes County. The state continues to take quarantine action to control the further spread of the disease. There is no evidence that CWD has affected the wild deer population in the state.

"The positive sample was taken from a single buck on a hunting preserve in Millersburg and tested as part of Ohio’s CWD monitoring program for captive white-tailed deer operations. The preserve had been under quarantine since April 24, 2014, and was subject to intensive monitoring and sampling protocols because of a known connection to a captive deer operation in Pennsylvania that tested positive for CWD earlier this year. The quarantine will remain enforced until the state is satisfied that disease transference can no longer occur.

“Ohio’s captive white-tail deer licensing program was enacted two years ago for the purpose of continuously monitoring the heath of the captive deer populations in the state to manage the spread of and exposure to diseases such as CWD. We have worked closely with the Pennsylvania Department of Agriculture to identify and trace back positive cases,” said State Veterinarian Dr. Tony Forshey. “We will continue to take aggressive steps to ensure that CWD does not pose a threat to the state’s wild deer population.”

"The state has quarantined 43 captive deer operations in Ohio since April 15, 2014, for receiving approximately 125 deer from operations in Pennsylvania that later tested positive for CWD. Twenty-two of those quarantines were lifted after negative CWD test results were confirmed in 53 of the suspect animals from Pennsylvania. ODA will continue to enforce quarantine restrictions on 21 operations, including five hunting preserves, until the department is satisfied that the threat of disease transference has passed.

"The disease is fatal in deer, elk and moose, but there is no evidence CWD can be transmitted to humans, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) and The World Health Organization. Though no human disease has been associated with CWD, the CDC recommends, as a precaution, that people or other animals do not eat any part of an animal diagnosed with or showing signs of CWD.

“We have no reason to believe that there has been transference to the state’s wild deer population,” said Scott Zody, chief of the ODNR Division of Wildlife. “With hunting season in progress, there are no CWD concerns that should prevent anyone from enjoying wild deer hunting in Ohio or from consuming meat from healthy animals.”

"The ODNR Division of Wildlife is recommending that hunters continue to take standard precautions such as shooting only animals that appear healthy, wearing rubber gloves when field-dressing their deer and washing thoroughly when finished. If hunters should observe a deer that appears unhealthy, they are encouraged to contact their local wildlife office or officer.

"Since 2002, the state has conducted surveillance throughout Ohio for the disease. State and federal officials will continue this regular sampling and testing throughout the hunting season to continue to monitor the health of the state’s wild deer population. Tissue samples from 753 deer killed on Ohio’s roads were collected from September 2013 through March 2014 and were tested for CWD.

"An additional 88 hunter-harvested mature white-tailed deer and nine deer displaying symptoms consistent with CWD were tested as well and were all negative.

"In response to this positive finding, the ODNR Division of Wildlife will increase sampling efforts in the wild deer population within six miles of the hunting preserve from which the CWD-positive deer came as well as near the other captive operations that are under quarantine. Those samples will include high-risk animals such as those killed on roads or exhibiting neurological symptoms as well as hunter-harvested deer in the area.

"CWD, first discovered in captive mule deer in Colorado in 1967, attacks the brains of infected deer, elk and moose, producing small lesions that eventually result in death. It is transmitted by direct animal-to-animal contact through saliva, feces and urine.

"Signs of the disease include weight loss, excessive salivation, increased drinking and urination, and abnormal behavior like stumbling, trembling and depression. Infected deer and elk may also allow unusually close approach by humans or natural predators. The disease is fatal in deer, and there is no known treatment or vaccine."

- Jeffrey L. Frischkorn
JFrischk@Ameritech.net